Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Antje Bormann's avatar

Having grown up and become a young adult in a socialist state (East Germany), usually described as part of the Communist Bloc (when only the USSR officially declared its transition from socialism to communism a handful of years before the fall of the Berlin Wall), allow me respectfully to disagree with this description of ‘communism’ from the article :”The other America, the one that buys fear, grievance, and over-priced gold shoes, has been told the big tent is filled with ‘communists’. No one explained to them what communism is and why calling Democrats communists is not only another lie to throw on the already putrid mountain of lies, but truly disrespectful to those who endured the pain of totalitarian rule by communist leaders. Under communism, people could not get basic food or health care because communists stole everything. Their world was violent and scary, filled with secret police, neighbors turning on neighbors, routine roundups of regime opponents. It was never the promised people’s paradise but rather, a system that gave leaders a pass to commit genocide without consequence.”

We did have basic foods, and enough for everyone, at subsidised retail prices which were the same in every shop of the land. Healthcare wad free, too, as was education, including university, with housing, culture, public transport again being subsidised and accessible to everyone despite the low income. Secret police and an informal spy network existed but it was an open secret and one simply took care of what one said to whom. My own paternal grandfather was coerced into becoming an IM at the Stasi but his chosen handle made it clear to the initiated that he wouldn’t provide any actionable information.

What was described in the article sounds to me a lot more like national socialism, which was already an attempt to subvert the idea if socialism with a totalitarian agenda. I am a little tired of people who weren’t even there trying to tell us how things were while conflating all sorts of things.

Expand full comment
Randolph Proksch's avatar

America had a moment in 1968, when hope could have been re-ignited … but RFK was assassinated and HHH was not the man. Ken Mo inspires us to celebrate that today, we now have the right woman for the moment!

https://youtu.be/FciQeRGYFlw?si=ti5BUvAO1WZmERnx

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts